The Cost of Inconsistency Aldo Marchiano Kaligis og Guðbjörg Lára Másdóttir skrifa 18. október 2023 10:01 The unfolding tragedy in Gaza is undeniably heart-wrenching. Our hearts go out to the Palestinians who have lost their lives during Israel's recent invasion. While the world watches, we are compelled to reflect on the larger issue at play: the glaring double standards in how we address human rights violations. In this article, we delve into the ongoing conflict in Gaza and its implications, focusing on the disproportionate responses and selective condemnation that echo across the global stage. The recent conflict in Gaza traces its origins to 7 October 2023, when Hamas launched an attack on Israel. Israel responded, and the cycle of violence has continued unabated. As of today, more than 1,900 Palestinians and 1,200 Israelis have tragically lost their lives. The devastating toll on human lives paints a grim picture of the ongoing conflict. In the face of this conflict, the WEIRD (White/Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Developed/Democratic) world has offered its perspectives. Criticisms have flowed, primarily directed at Hamas, citing the number of civilian casualties on the Israeli side. Strikingly, the same level of scrutiny has not been extended to Israel despite its counterattacks being perceived as highly disproportionate. Leaders from WEIRD countries have endorsed Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas's attacks. Iceland's Minister of Foreign Affairs, Þórdís Kolbrún Reykfjörð Gylfadóttir, and the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, have expressed unwavering support for Israel's actions. However, the glaring omission in their statements is the failure to acknowledge concerns of genocide, crimes against humanity, or apartheid targeting Palestinians. Paradoxically, these statements seem at odds with previous policies and comments. For example, Iceland was the pioneer among Western and Northern European countries in recognizing Palestine as an independent state back in 2011. This recognition extended beyond politics to society, as seen when Iceland's sensational heavy metal Eurovision performance by Hatari involved raising Palestinian flags during the event hosted in Israel in 2019. On the other hand, in 2022, von der Leyen strongly criticized Russia's military aggression in Ukraine, characterizing the attack as "grossly violating international law and undermining European and global security and stability." The double standards applied to Israel's most recent killing spree are not just a matter of rhetoric; they have far-reaching implications for global human rights efforts. The principles of universality, indivisibility, equality, and non-discrimination that underpin human rights may be undermined when responses from WEIRD countries – often dubbed as the champions of human rights – diverge from these ideals. Indonesia provides a pertinent case study, taking inspiration from WEIRD countries' inconsistent responses to take a hypocritical turn when responding to allegations of human rights violations. For example, while vocally expressing concern for Gaza, Indonesia's own human rights issues, particularly in its westernmost region, Papua, have been met with deflection. On 10 October 2023, President Joko Widodo urged "the immediate end of war and violence to avoid further human casualties and damages of property because conflict escalation may give rise to further humanitarian impact" and added, "The root of the conflict, namely the occupation of the territory of Palestine by Israel, must immediately be resolved." However, the statement came against prolonged human rights violations and armed forces occupation by Indonesia in Papua. For decades, Indonesia has conducted military operations in Papua to quell the Papuans' self-independence claims, resulting in an estimated loss of life between 2,000 and 500,000individuals. Experts argue that these campaigns amount to slow genocide. This is substantiated by the demographic shift observed over the years: in the 1970s, Indigenous Papuans constituted 96 percent of the population, yet by 2010, that number had dwindled to just 48 percent. The Indonesian government has consistently denied allegations of human rights violations in Papua, deflecting international concern. In 2019, a government spokesperson expressed displeasureat Papua being included on the formal agenda of the Pacific Islands Forum's leaders' meeting in Tuvalu, warning that this could set a dangerous precedent for external interference in the domestic affairs of other nations. In conclusion, the double standards in addressing human rights issues are not just a matter of diplomatic discourse. These inconsistencies can have severe implications for global justice and the pursuit of accountability. The principles of universality, indivisibility, equality, and non-discrimination should be upheld universally, irrespective of political or strategic interests. As the world grapples with the ongoing conflict in Gaza, we are reminded that the fight for human rights must transcend geopolitical biases and confront the selective application of these principles for the betterment of all. Authors work for Aurora Foundation Sierra Leone and Amnesty International Indonesia. Viltu birta grein á Vísi? Sendu okkur póst. Senda grein Átök í Ísrael og Palestínu Mest lesið Flokkur fólksins eða flokkun fólksins? Halldóra Lillý Jóhannsdóttir Skoðun Hver ætlar að bera ábyrgð á mannslífi? Sævar Þór Jónsson Skoðun Er útlegð á innleið? Reyn Alpha Magnúsdóttir Skoðun Íslendingar flytja út fisk og líka ofbeldismenn Guðný S. Bjarnadóttir Skoðun Fyrst flúðu þau Reykjavíkurborg… Diljá Mist Einarsdóttir Skoðun Horfumst í augu Kristín Thoroddsen Skoðun Betri nýting á tíma og fjármunum Reykjavíkurborgar 2/3 Magnea Gná Jóhannsdóttir Skoðun Skólarnir lokaðir - myglan vinnur Guðmundur Þórir Sigurðsson Skoðun Börn á flótta – nýtt líf, nýtt tungumál og nýtt tækifæri í íslenskum grunnskólum Friðþjófur Helgi Karlsson Skoðun 30 silfurpeningar dýralækna? 125.000 lítrar af blóði tappaðir af 4088 merum (með valdi), af eiðsvörðum dýralæknum, 2023 Ole Anton Bieltvedt Skoðun Skoðun Skoðun Fyrst flúðu þau Reykjavíkurborg… Diljá Mist Einarsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Er útlegð á innleið? Reyn Alpha Magnúsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Leiðsögundurinn Gaur gerir mig að betri manneskju Þorkell J. Steindal skrifar Skoðun Börn á flótta – nýtt líf, nýtt tungumál og nýtt tækifæri í íslenskum grunnskólum Friðþjófur Helgi Karlsson skrifar Skoðun Skólarnir lokaðir - myglan vinnur Guðmundur Þórir Sigurðsson skrifar Skoðun Flokkur fólksins eða flokkun fólksins? Halldóra Lillý Jóhannsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Betri nýting á tíma og fjármunum Reykjavíkurborgar 2/3 Magnea Gná Jóhannsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Hver ætlar að bera ábyrgð á mannslífi? Sævar Þór Jónsson skrifar Skoðun Horfumst í augu Kristín Thoroddsen skrifar Skoðun 30 silfurpeningar dýralækna? 125.000 lítrar af blóði tappaðir af 4088 merum (með valdi), af eiðsvörðum dýralæknum, 2023 Ole Anton Bieltvedt skrifar Skoðun Opið bréf til heilbrigðisráðherra: Iðjuþjálfar – mikilvægur mannauður í geðheilbrigðisþjónustu framtíðarinnar Erna Rut Elvarsdóttir,Lilja Logadóttir, Rebekka Lind Hjaltadóttir,Sandra Dís Sigurðardóttir skrifar Skoðun Saga Israa á Gaza og hvernig hægt er að verða að liði Katrín Harðardóttir,Israa Saed skrifar Skoðun Fordómar frá sálfélagslegu sjónarhorni Sóley Dröfn Davíðsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Er aldur bara tala? Teitur Guðmundsson skrifar Skoðun Íslendingar flytja út fisk og líka ofbeldismenn Guðný S. Bjarnadóttir skrifar Skoðun Iðjuþjálfar í leik- og grunnskólum: Tækifæri í baráttunni gegn agavanda og skólaforðun Hekla Björt Birkisdóttir,Hrefna Dagbjört Arnardóttir,Inga Fríða Guðbjörnsdóttir,Íris Kristrún Kristmundsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Frans páfi kvaddur eða meðtekinn? Bjarni Karlsson skrifar Skoðun Lægjum öldurnar Halla Hrund Logadóttir skrifar Skoðun Að hata einhvern sem þú þarft á að halda? Katrín Pétursdóttir skrifar Skoðun Íslenskar pyndingar Guðmundur Ingi Þóroddsson skrifar Skoðun SFS, Exit og norska leiðin þeirra Jón Kaldal skrifar Skoðun Friður - í framsöguhætti eða viðtengingarhætti? Bryndís Schram skrifar Skoðun Næringarfræði er lykillinn að betri heilsu, viltu vera með? Guðrún Nanna Egilsdóttir skrifar Skoðun Löngu þarft samtal um hóp sem gleymist! Katarzyna Kubiś skrifar Skoðun Menntun fyrir öll – nema okkur Haukur Guðmundsson skrifar Skoðun Það er ekki hægt að loka augunum fyrir þessum veruleika Davíð Bergmann skrifar Skoðun Kirkjugarðsballið: Eiga Íslendingar að mæta þar? Birgir Dýrfjörð skrifar Skoðun Að sækja gullið (okkar) Þröstur Friðfinnsson skrifar Skoðun Til hamingju blaðamenn! Hjálmar Jónsson skrifar Skoðun Stormur í Þjóðleikhúsinu Bubbi Morthens skrifar Sjá meira
The unfolding tragedy in Gaza is undeniably heart-wrenching. Our hearts go out to the Palestinians who have lost their lives during Israel's recent invasion. While the world watches, we are compelled to reflect on the larger issue at play: the glaring double standards in how we address human rights violations. In this article, we delve into the ongoing conflict in Gaza and its implications, focusing on the disproportionate responses and selective condemnation that echo across the global stage. The recent conflict in Gaza traces its origins to 7 October 2023, when Hamas launched an attack on Israel. Israel responded, and the cycle of violence has continued unabated. As of today, more than 1,900 Palestinians and 1,200 Israelis have tragically lost their lives. The devastating toll on human lives paints a grim picture of the ongoing conflict. In the face of this conflict, the WEIRD (White/Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Developed/Democratic) world has offered its perspectives. Criticisms have flowed, primarily directed at Hamas, citing the number of civilian casualties on the Israeli side. Strikingly, the same level of scrutiny has not been extended to Israel despite its counterattacks being perceived as highly disproportionate. Leaders from WEIRD countries have endorsed Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas's attacks. Iceland's Minister of Foreign Affairs, Þórdís Kolbrún Reykfjörð Gylfadóttir, and the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, have expressed unwavering support for Israel's actions. However, the glaring omission in their statements is the failure to acknowledge concerns of genocide, crimes against humanity, or apartheid targeting Palestinians. Paradoxically, these statements seem at odds with previous policies and comments. For example, Iceland was the pioneer among Western and Northern European countries in recognizing Palestine as an independent state back in 2011. This recognition extended beyond politics to society, as seen when Iceland's sensational heavy metal Eurovision performance by Hatari involved raising Palestinian flags during the event hosted in Israel in 2019. On the other hand, in 2022, von der Leyen strongly criticized Russia's military aggression in Ukraine, characterizing the attack as "grossly violating international law and undermining European and global security and stability." The double standards applied to Israel's most recent killing spree are not just a matter of rhetoric; they have far-reaching implications for global human rights efforts. The principles of universality, indivisibility, equality, and non-discrimination that underpin human rights may be undermined when responses from WEIRD countries – often dubbed as the champions of human rights – diverge from these ideals. Indonesia provides a pertinent case study, taking inspiration from WEIRD countries' inconsistent responses to take a hypocritical turn when responding to allegations of human rights violations. For example, while vocally expressing concern for Gaza, Indonesia's own human rights issues, particularly in its westernmost region, Papua, have been met with deflection. On 10 October 2023, President Joko Widodo urged "the immediate end of war and violence to avoid further human casualties and damages of property because conflict escalation may give rise to further humanitarian impact" and added, "The root of the conflict, namely the occupation of the territory of Palestine by Israel, must immediately be resolved." However, the statement came against prolonged human rights violations and armed forces occupation by Indonesia in Papua. For decades, Indonesia has conducted military operations in Papua to quell the Papuans' self-independence claims, resulting in an estimated loss of life between 2,000 and 500,000individuals. Experts argue that these campaigns amount to slow genocide. This is substantiated by the demographic shift observed over the years: in the 1970s, Indigenous Papuans constituted 96 percent of the population, yet by 2010, that number had dwindled to just 48 percent. The Indonesian government has consistently denied allegations of human rights violations in Papua, deflecting international concern. In 2019, a government spokesperson expressed displeasureat Papua being included on the formal agenda of the Pacific Islands Forum's leaders' meeting in Tuvalu, warning that this could set a dangerous precedent for external interference in the domestic affairs of other nations. In conclusion, the double standards in addressing human rights issues are not just a matter of diplomatic discourse. These inconsistencies can have severe implications for global justice and the pursuit of accountability. The principles of universality, indivisibility, equality, and non-discrimination should be upheld universally, irrespective of political or strategic interests. As the world grapples with the ongoing conflict in Gaza, we are reminded that the fight for human rights must transcend geopolitical biases and confront the selective application of these principles for the betterment of all. Authors work for Aurora Foundation Sierra Leone and Amnesty International Indonesia.
Börn á flótta – nýtt líf, nýtt tungumál og nýtt tækifæri í íslenskum grunnskólum Friðþjófur Helgi Karlsson Skoðun
30 silfurpeningar dýralækna? 125.000 lítrar af blóði tappaðir af 4088 merum (með valdi), af eiðsvörðum dýralæknum, 2023 Ole Anton Bieltvedt Skoðun
Skoðun Börn á flótta – nýtt líf, nýtt tungumál og nýtt tækifæri í íslenskum grunnskólum Friðþjófur Helgi Karlsson skrifar
Skoðun 30 silfurpeningar dýralækna? 125.000 lítrar af blóði tappaðir af 4088 merum (með valdi), af eiðsvörðum dýralæknum, 2023 Ole Anton Bieltvedt skrifar
Skoðun Opið bréf til heilbrigðisráðherra: Iðjuþjálfar – mikilvægur mannauður í geðheilbrigðisþjónustu framtíðarinnar Erna Rut Elvarsdóttir,Lilja Logadóttir, Rebekka Lind Hjaltadóttir,Sandra Dís Sigurðardóttir skrifar
Skoðun Iðjuþjálfar í leik- og grunnskólum: Tækifæri í baráttunni gegn agavanda og skólaforðun Hekla Björt Birkisdóttir,Hrefna Dagbjört Arnardóttir,Inga Fríða Guðbjörnsdóttir,Íris Kristrún Kristmundsdóttir skrifar
Börn á flótta – nýtt líf, nýtt tungumál og nýtt tækifæri í íslenskum grunnskólum Friðþjófur Helgi Karlsson Skoðun
30 silfurpeningar dýralækna? 125.000 lítrar af blóði tappaðir af 4088 merum (með valdi), af eiðsvörðum dýralæknum, 2023 Ole Anton Bieltvedt Skoðun